4290 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901

Renovations

Seven Signs Your Pool Is Ready for Resurfacing

June 8, 2026 · 5 min read

Renovated Naples Florida pool with new glass tile and travertine deck

Rough plaster, stubborn stains and creeping water loss are your pool telling you the surface has reached the end of its life.

The signs to watch for

Interior finishes in Florida typically last 8 to 15 years depending on material and water chemistry. Long before total failure, the pool gives you warnings.

  • Surface feels rough or chalky underfoot
  • Stains that return within weeks of every acid treatment
  • Visible plaster erosion exposing the gray shell beneath
  • Spider cracks spreading across the floor or walls
  • Waterline tile falling off or grout washing out
  • Water loss beyond normal evaporation
  • Chemical demand climbing for no obvious reason

Choosing a finish

Standard marcite is the least expensive but the shortest lived. Quartz finishes add durability and color depth for a modest premium. Pebble finishes cost the most up front and routinely outlast everything else, which is why they dominate high-end SWFL remodels.

What a remodel involves

Draining, chipping out the old surface, replacing waterline tile and coping, applying the new finish, then a careful startup and brushing schedule for the first two weeks. Most residential projects run one to three weeks depending on scope and inspection timing.

Since the pool is already empty, it is also the cheapest moment to add LED lighting, upgrade plumbing, or modernize the equipment pad.

← All articles

Ready to Get Started?

Contact Colonial Pool & Spa, Inc. for a free consultation and a detailed quote anywhere in Southwest Florida.